fbpx
Connect with us

Business

We Used 99designs For Logos: Here’s Our Review

Published

on

What is it like to use 99designs? We’re going to go through the process of creating a design contest from start to finish to show you what the entire experience is like, so you can decide for yourself if 99designs is for you. For this 99designs review, we’re going to follow all instructions given and document each step of our journey for you to see below.

For this test project, we’re going to submit a contest for Owner’s Mag logo to see if 99designs can interpret a better logo for us. The chances of me getting this approved and having the CEO change the logo is practically 0, but this will be a fun project that everyone in our office can contribute feedback to. It couldn’t hurt, right?

1. Creating our design project

We went ahead and searched “Logo” and went through the process of creating the logo project. When selecting the business category, surprisingly there’s nothing related to digital publication, news, or publisher there. We went ahead and chose “Internet” as our category.

2. Choosing a name

Now it’s time to name our project. We’re going to call this one “Owner’s Mag Logo Design”. Not sure if I’ll ever get the approval to change the logo, but it’ll be a fun project that everyone at the office can give input on.

3. Types of logo

Logos come in all different shapes, themes, and types. They can be just a word logo, icons, abstract, or something unique with a mascot. Here’s where you can tell the 99designers what type of logo you want.

4. Choosing a style

I like this section a lot. Sometimes it’s difficult to actually describe what you want. Here, you can browse through a long list of logo designs that cover a wide spectrum of styling. Select the ones that best fit your taste and it’ll give the 99designers a better idea of what you want.

I went ahead and chose a few text-focused logo, since Owner’s Mag is a text-only logo. The selected examples in the screenshot above aren’t the ones I chose.

5. Brand Style Meter

I’ll be honest, this section is a bit weird for me. On this page, 99design asked me to explain the style I want using different sliding scales. There’s more than the 3 listed in the image above. I personally had a hard time deciding if Owner’s mag logo should be “Classic” or “Modern”, “Mature” or “Youthful”. Femine vs Masculine I can work with. But the other categories aren’t intuitive for me.

6. Choosing Colors

Now it’s time to pick our color preferences. I stuck with “Reds”.

7. Writing project brief

Filling out the project brief didn’t take too long. The questions were straight forward and all makes sense. It is odd that the project brief itself is this far down the process.

8. Choose your package

So far, we haven’t paid 99designs anything. Now it’s time for us to pick a tier for our plan. Although the Logo starts at $299, that’s actually for the Bronze tier. The higher tier you go, the more submissions and higher quality the work will be. Or at least that’s what 99designs promise.

For this, we chose the Silver $499 plan. We’ll be expecting about 60 designs to be submitted with this package.

9. Add-ons

In addition to the $499 we’re paying for the Silver tier, 99designs will upsell us for a few things. Some of these I think makes sense, others I felt should be included in the price I’m paying.

Personal Creative Consultant ($129) actually looks like customer support to me. I’m not a designer. Of course, I will need some help through this process. I felt like this should’ve already been included in the price instead of being a $129 add-on.

Guaranteed doesn’t cost anything. But it will null your money-back guarantee. This ensures the designer WILL get paid if they make it to the final round. Because of 99designs’ pay structure, this makes your project much more appealing to designers and more will likely submit drafts if you opt out of their guarantee.

Private ($59), this came as a shocker. I didn’t know this would even be public. Why my project is even open to the public in the first place is beyond me. This doesn’t feel right. Paying $59 just so 99designs keep my designs private seems like a scare tactic for me to cough up more money. Not a fan.

Duration lets you pay a bit more for faster delivery. For this, I feel the prices are fair and it’s typical to pay more for expedited work anyway. You can pay $39 for 3 day instead of 4 day delivery, $59 for 2 days, and $79 for 1 day.

9. Complete! Now we wait…

I opted to not purchase any add-ons for this review. Once paid, we’re redirected to 99designs’ dashboard where we can see the estimated timeline for the project. From today, it’ll take about 4 days for all of the designs to be submitted. Each day some designers will submit their work and on the final day, the round will be closed and we have 4 days to pick finalists.

The Designs Are In!

First off, I was very disappointed that we only received 17 designs instead of the promised 60. I contacted 99designs support about the issue and they claim that they don’t guarantee “60”, even though their pricing tiers clearly listed “Expect ~60 designs”.

Maybe the 17 designs we received are good? I’ll let you be the judge of that before we give our verdict.

Here are the 17 designs that 99designers submitted to us after 4 days.

What does our office think?

We passed the designs around our office to get some initial thoughts. Most thought the designs were random and not aligned with any of the directions given. Some look templated. Others look like they just slap a random icon in front of the text and call it a logo.

Overall, none of us were impressed by the results thus far. We eventually picked #6 to give feedback just to move the process along, not because we love the design. We felt let down that only 17 versions were submitted since 99designs promised we’d get around 60 designs to choose from.

We submitted our revisions and now wait for our designer to spin something back to us.

4 days later…

We received new versions of logo #6 within about 3-4 days. Personally I wasn’t happy with the new versions, but I shared the new designs with the office. You can probably guess how we all felt about the new drafts. Results…were disappointing and not what we had suggested. At this point, we didn’t feel compelled to give any further instructions or move the project to the final round.

We’re not happy

We decided not to continue the project given we’re not happy with any of the drafts so far. Even revisions were still so far off what we would even accept. I understand graphic design is subjective, and that sometimes you just have a difficult client. I assure you, we’re not that difficult and was looking for a very simple logo.

It was hard for us to justify even moving to the final round given the designers barely followed our directions. We specifically asked them to design the logo using our RED, and some of them ignored it completely. We asked them to NOT use any icons and just keep it text-based, yet there were logos with random icons.

Getting a Refund

Our experience could be a unique case and your experience could be much more pleasant. We eventually asked for a refund and was met with another obstacle. You can’t get a refund on the website, they request a call to speak to you to “verify” your identity before releasing your refund.

This is an annoying step clearly put in place just to discourage refunds. I oblige and got on a call with a representative. The rep was understanding and didn’t try too hard to sell me, which I appreciated. Our refund was promptly processed afterward.

Final Verdict

Our experience with 99designs has been mixed. I like how intuitive the website is and how easy it was to get your logo project started. The biggest let down were the number of submissions we received (17 instead of the promised 60) and the quality of each design. You can judge for yourself. Looking at the logos submitted, I didn’t feel like we got even intermediate level designers. These just felt rushed, patched together, and overall unpolished work.

Giving revision was difficult because most of the designs were so far off base. I didn’t know where to start, except tell the designer to re-read my project brief and start over.

Overall, it wasn’t the best experience for us. We would’ve gladly paid an agency or a freelancer the same amount and get more dedicated care and attention to produce 2-3 good logos instead of 17 poorly design random logos.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Business

5 Highest Rated Design Services Used by Big Brands & Agencies

Published

on

As a business, partnering with a design company that can help you reach your design, branding, and even revenue goals is essential. However, comparing companies can quickly turn into a full-time job. That’s why we’ve narrowed down the top design companies according to Trustpilot and Google, both well-established sites where real customers leave reviews.

Let’s look at the highest-rated graphic design companies and what they offer so you can choose what makes sense for your brand and budget.

1. Penji

Trustpilot rating: 4.8

One of the most trusted design services for startups and agencies is Penji. Penji’s business model is unique because they offer an unlimited graphic design subscription. You simply pay a flat monthly fee and get as many designs as you need for yourself or your clients. Their scope of service spans over 100 design categories, which means they can handle your website, branding materials, ad designs, packaging designs, and more. Agencies rely on Penji to help them manage various client projects and radically increase their design output if needed.

Penji has three plans to choose from, all of which are unlimited but the details vary. In higher plans, you can access motion graphics and even work with an Art Director and Figma Web Designer. The platform is user-friendly, making it easy to submit design briefs, collaborate with your team, and contact your assigned designer directly.

Unlike some of the companies on this list, Penji has a dedicated design team. So if you don’t want to take a chance on freelancers, you can get to know Penji’s designers and who works best with you. Read our review of Penji here and get 25% off when you subscribe. You can pause or cancel anytime.

What can you get from an unlimited graphic design service?

  • Logos
  • Business cards
  • Web and app designs
  • Presentation designs
  • Marketing materials
  • Marketing designs
  • Digital ads
  • Billboards
  • Magazines
  • Packaging
  • Merchandise
  • Illustrations
  • And more

Pricing:

  • Starter – $499/mo
  • Marketer – $995/mo
  • Agency – $1497/mo

2. Clay

Google rating: 4.8

Clay is a widely known and respected design agency that has worked with such names as Slack, Stripe, and Meta. They’re a full-service agency who specialize in branding, website design, and content creation. This is a diverse company that honed its creativity with past projects like a food app, a payroll management platform, an interior design website, and more.

Clay has a knack for covering all the details and ensuring they go all out for each project. Pricing is handled on a case by case basis as the company operates like a traditional full-service design agency. They’re a great option for brands with larger budgets who have specific projects they want to accomplish – eg. rebrands, app builds. They also offer art direction and classic graphic design services like illustration and animation.

3. Toptal

Trustpilot rating: 4.7

If you want to hire a freelancer, but you’ve been disappointed in the past, you might be hesitant to try again. Fortunately, Toptal has taken a different approach from platforms like Fiverr and Upwork. They offer a more upscale experience of freelance matching with highly experienced professionals (sometimes with impressive backgrounds like being a former Google employee). Many companies lean on Toptal for reliable freelancers including Zendesk and Doordash.

With Toptal, you can hire a freelancer part-time or full-time. You’ll simply answer a few questions about your business on their website. If you don’t like the work of the first designer you’re matched with in the early phase, Toptal will start the matching process over again so they can find you a better match.

Another benefit of Toptal is that they have professionals in various design niches. They offer UX and UI designers product designers, game designers, creative directors, and more.

4. Webdew

Trustpilot rating: 4.8

Webdew is a lesser-known company, but their review rating speaks for itself. Their skilled developers have a UI/UX focus and will take you through the entire design process from wireframe design to backend development. They also handle things like website migration and WordPress development.

Webdew is anything but a one-trick pony. They offer web design, video production, marketing, and Hubspot-related services. But if you’re looking for other graphic design services like logo design or illustration, you’ll have to look elsewhere.

5. DesignCrowd

Trustpilot rating: 4.7

DesignCrowd is an innovative platform that connects businesses with freelance designers from around the world. By leveraging the power of crowdsourcing, DesignCrowd allows clients to post design projects and receive a wide variety of submissions from designers. This approach not only provides clients with creative options but also allows designers to compete on a global stage, showcasing their skills and gaining new opportunities. The platform covers many design mediums like logos, websites, and t-shirts making it a versatile solution for enterprises of any size.

DesignCrowd’s process is straightforward and user-friendly. Clients start by outlining their design requirements and budget. This is then made visible to the platform’s extensive network of designers. Interested designers submit their concepts, and the client can provide feedback, request revisions, and ultimately choose their favorite design. The competitive environment encourages high-quality submissions so you get great results. Additionally, they offer a satisfaction guarantee, so there’s no risk.

The value of signing up for an unlimited design service

1. Saves You Time

Hiring freelancers can take days or even weeks. You have to find the right person, check their availability, and direct them at each step of the design project. You can save time by subscribing to an unlimited graphic design service. These services have already done the vetting, which helps you cut the time needed to hire a freelancer & get usable work from them. These services have teams of designers with different skillsets so you can simply swap designers if you don’t like the direction you project is going in.

2. Saves You Money

Some graphic design services offer packages or bundles to help you save money that would be going to branding, social media managers, or ad creators. The design subscription model lets you pick to plan that offers only what you need and request multiple designs for a flat monthly fee. Unlimited revisions are built into the plan. So you’ll never pay extra fees or wait weeks for a simple project to be completed.

3. You Partner with Reliable Pro Designers

Since graphic design services manage the hiring process, they ensure the designers working for them are reliable and highly trained. Some freelancers are new to the industry, lack follow-through, or simply don’t know how to navigate professional conversations. Graphic design services guarantee that you’ll communicate directly with mature designers who respond to your requests and understand your vision.

4. You Double Your Design Output

For some companies like agencies, design output is critical. You need many different types of design projects completed by specific deadlines. You also need to manage multiple brands, which unlimited design teams are accustomed to helping agencies do.

With free trials and money-back guarantees, there’s no risk in trying out a new design service – You may just be surprised by how much work it takes off your team’s plate.

Continue Reading

Business

TikTok Is Toast: Get the Secret Weapon Brands are Using to Power Through

Published

on

Just when you thought the drama surrounding TikTok couldn’t get any juicier, the US government drops a bombshell. Just days ago, President Biden signed a bill that could ban TikTok across the entire country. 

TikTok has been asked to find a “new, non-Chinese owner” within the next 9 months according to CNN. The company is within its rights to comply (which will be tough) or file a lawsuit. Unsurprisingly, TikTok’s parent company ByteDance is already leaning toward the latter, announcing it’s ready for a legal battle.

With over 170 million Americans entrenched in the app, the prospect of its sudden disappearance sparks more questions than answers. What does a “ban” actually entail? For one, it doesn’t mean you’ll face legal action as an individual who still uses TikTok. And it doesn’t mean the app will magically vanish if you already have it downloaded.

Instead, the ban threatens to remove TikTok from Apple and Google’s app stores, which means no more updates, security patches, or bug fixes. This could pose a security risk to TikTok’s loyal user base.

But fear not, social media enthusiasts, because while the chaos unfolds, brands and influencers can use this time to get clear on their strategy. While the rest of the digital world is losing its mind, you can set your brand up to thrive like never before.

Enter Penji: Your Secret Weapon for Social Media Domination

It’s hard to stay relevant and have an effective social media strategy when things are so volatile in the digital world. But that’s only really true if you’re working alone.  

Particularly for marketing, design, branding, and social media agencies, getting help from professionals is crucial. You likely need copywriters, marketers, designers, and coders as the bare minimum.

So who’s Penji.. and who cares? 

You could say Penji is an ‘all-in-one chaos solution’ for brands with lots to do and little time to do it. They’re a design team that creates the visual assets that power numerous brands year-round. Penji can create custom:

  • Ad designs
  • Organic social posts
  • Custom illustrations
  • Logos & branding
  • Blog graphics
  • Infographics
  • Email templates
  • Landing pages
  • Web & app designs
  • And more

If you can name it, Penji can probably design it. Brands are getting crazy results. For example: 

RevenueZen saw a 25% increase in customer engagement and a 20% boost in sales after partnering with Penji for their new website.

Rush Order Tees upped their productivity by 2200% with the help of just 5 Penji designers who mastered their brand visuals.

How does it work?

Penji is an unlimited graphic design service, which means they don’t put limits on how many designs you can get each month. You pay a flat monthly fee and request any designs, anytime. There’s no contract, so you can cancel or pause anytime too. 

Step 1: Create a Project: Go to Penji’s dashboard and select “Create a Project.” Choose a category (eg. logo) and provide all the details your designer needs to knock it out of the park.

Step 2: Get Matched Right Away: Once you’ve submitted your design brief, you’ll be matched with a pro designer via our AI matching system. From here, just sit back and relax.

Step 3: Review & Give Feedback: Within 24 to 48 hours, you’ll receive the first draft of your design. Provide point-and-click feedback directly on a project, and the designer will make revisions until you’re completely satisfied. There’s no limit to revisions, and you can swap designers if you don’t like the direction.

Step 4: Mark as Complete and Download: Once you’re happy with a project, simply mark it as complete. You can then download the files directly from the Penji platform, no need for external links or emails. Your files are securely stored in the cloud, ensuring easy access whenever you need them.

Not only can you communicate directly with your designers, but also creative assistants, project managers, or art directors depending on which plan you choose.

Never Hire an Unreliable Designer Again

For brands dealing with vetting and hiring headaches, Penji offers a hassle-free alternative. By eliminating the need for constant hiring/firing and payroll management, brands can bypass the headaches associated with maintaining a freelance (or in-house) team. Instead, you can tap into Penji’s pool of vetted creative talent, handpicked to meet the demands of even the pickiest clients.

Retain More Customers with a Bulletproof Brand Identity


Customer retention is another area where Penji helps businesses shine. By providing on-brand, consistent quality across every project, you’ll build trust and loyalty with your clients. With a dedicated team of creatives, project coordinators, and quality control experts, Penji ensures you put your best foot forward at every touchpoint. That means your customers won’t hesitate to pick you over a competitor – the design does the convincing.

The bottom line? With costs roughly 70% lower than hiring in-house designers, Penji offers a cost-effective solution without skimping on quality or speed. You’ll boost your production rates drastically for a fraction of what you’re used to spending. 

So don’t let the TikTok ban scare you away from focusing on social media growth. Partner with a design team that just gets you – and your social media strategy will start running like clockwork.

Ready to Win at Social Media?

If your interest is peaked and you’re ready to power your social media channels with more ease than ever, watch a quick demo to see how you can get all the designs you need in one place.

Continue Reading

Business

Fiverr vs Penji vs Canva: Who’s Your Winner?

Published

on

Solid graphic design is no longer a luxury – It’s a must-have. You don’t want to skimp out on design, especially when your competitors aren’t. Fortunately, accessing professional graphic design has never been easier. Businesses have multiple options: hiring freelance graphic designers, creating their own designs, or subscribing to graphic design services. In this post, we’ll look at the 3 leading platform for each of these avenues so you can decide who’s the best option for you: Fiverr, Penji, or Canva?

Companies Overview

Let’s start with a brief introduction to each company.

Fiverr

fiverr logo

Fiverr is a freelance gig platform for hiring remote workers, like web developers, podcast editors, video editors, and many more. Graphic designers are also available to hire on Fiverr with a wide scope of services. On Fiverr, you can browse various design styles to find the right designer for your project.

Penji

penji logo

Penji is a subscription-based graphic design service. You can subscribe and request as many designs projects as you want on a rolling basis. With Penji, you get access to 120+ design types, including web and app designs, presentation designs, motion designs, and illustrations. Plus access to art directors or project managers depending on what tier you choose.

Canva

canva logo

Canva is a do-it-yourself graphic design application that will help you design anything related to your business. You don’t need graphic design experience to use Canva. They offer templates to help you get started with designs like YouTube thumbnails or ads. Plus, you can edit those templates based on your unique branding.

Features

Fiverr

fiverr graphic design page

Fiverr provides businesses with two ways to find freelancers. First, you can find them using the search bar. Type “graphic designer” and find available designers to collaborate with. You can narrow your search by finding designers based on your design needs. For instance, you can browse “logo designers” instead of graphic designers.

As you select graphic designers, you can see that designers offer various plans depending on your design project. Plus, they indicate the following:

  • Number of designs they can create
  • Number of revisions
  • Turnaround time

Plus, you can also find reviews from previous clients to know their working experience with one of your top choices.

The other way to find freelancers is the Fiverr Enterprise platform. Fiverr specialists will help you find the best graphic designers, creatives, and other employees for your team. Plus, the platform includes onboarding, management, payment, and compliance.

Penji

penji webpage

Penji has many features to get you started, from submitting your first request to chatting directly with your designers. You simple click “Create” in the top right corner of the dashboard, submit your design brief, and get matched with the appropriate designer right away.

Here’s what to expect when subscribed to Penji:

  • Request 120+ designs
  • Get matched with the best designer for your project
  • Swap designers if needed
  • Manage multiple brands
  • Point and click revisions
  • Team collaboration
  • Designer chat window
  • Real-time updates

Canva

canva homepage

Meanwhile, Canva is a software loaded with many intuitive features to help you design your own projects. Features depend on the plan you choose. However, here are the basics:

  • Drag-and-drop editor
  • Access to 1 million templates, 3 million photos and videos, and thousands of design types
  • AI-generated designs
  • Printing and delivery

However, if you need more than that, you can access the following on the paid plans:

  • Resize and translate designs
  • Brand kits
  • Remove backgrounds
  • 1TB of cloud storage
  • 24/7 customer support

Turnaround Time

Turnaround time for Fiverr freelancers depends heavily on the graphic designer. They will indicate how long the delivery date would be. Some designers are quick (1-2 days) while others will take weeks for more involved projects.

Penji guarantees a 1 to 2-day turnaround time on most designs. If you’re subscribed to the Agency plan, they can even ensure same-day turnaround. However, complex projects like web or app designs will take longer.

Of course if you are using Canva, turnaround time is simply however long the project takes you! Again, this can vary depending on your design skills and whether or not you find the design elements you’re looking for.

Pricing

fiverr profile
example of a Fiverr profile with pricing page

Fiverr pricing depends on what designs you need. But as the name suggests, Fiverr refers to the $5 starting point that freelancers can charge clients with when working with them. However, there’s always the risk of poor quality. It’s best to vet each designer carefully and choose something reasonably priced.

Penji’s pricing is simple because you pay a flat monthly rate for all design work. Here are the pricing options depending on what tier of service you choose:

Lastly, Canva has three pricing tiers, depending on your needs and budget.

  • Canva – Free
  • Canva Pro – $15/mo
  • Canva for Teams – $10/mo (minimum 3 users)

Design Work and Production

Design work by Fiverr freelancers varies from experience level to design specialties. Many Fiverr freelancers produce decent work for clients, considering the rates they charge. However, not all design work from Fiverr is 100% the best. Considering Fiverr is the best for short-term work, expect one or few design variations for a project.

For Canva, we can use templates as the point of comparison for design work. Thousands of creators submit their templates to the graphic design software. Many templates look the same because it is the trend or looks modern. Regardless, Canva templates look decent to use as the base design for your brand. However, you need to modify it to your brand to avoid using similar templates from competitors or other brands.

Finally, Penji produces highly custom designs for clients. Because the price point is a bit higher, their design team can take the time to ensure you get the exact version of what you’re looking for. Penji isn’t a freelance platform, so you may get the chance to work with the same designers again and again (especially if you prefer their work).

Competitor Analysis

graphic designer

One fair comparison to make is between Fiverr and Penji since both deal with actual designers and their work. Here are a couple of comparison points for these two services to help you narrow your options further.

  • Design variations – Fiverr freelancers can create a few variations. Meanwhile, Penji designers can produce multiple variations since you can switch between designers.
  • Work volume – Fiverr designers can produce a limited number of designs, depending on plan inclusions. Ideally, they’re a good option for one-off projects. However, Penji can produce more than 10+ designs, especially if you have a monthly volume of designs.
  • Comfort – Penji allows you to sit back and run your company since it’s an extension of your team. Meanwhile, you need to browse and interview freelancers on Fiverr. Plus, you have to worry about payment and management.

But if we were to put Canva back into the equation, Canva has the upper hand in pricing. Plus, if you’re creative enough, you can produce great brand designs without the help of designers.

Final Thoughts

Graphic design work can be done and delivered in three main ways: doing it yourself, hiring a freelancer, or subscribing to a graphic design service. In this three-way showdown, each has its strengths and weaknesses. The three services have different models, which could benefit users or subscribers in getting their designs. It’s up to you which is the best design service for your situation. Good luck!

Continue Reading

Trending